How do you compare two multifamily management proposals?
Give both firms the same building facts and compare the same period and service scope. Ask what is included, what is billed separately, who handles the books and what happens at handoff. Record who can authorize work and what the owner will receive each month.
Use one worksheet for both proposals
Ask each firm to complete the same rows using the same collection assumption, leasing activity and transition date. For a smaller building, make sure minimums and per-event charges are visible. For a larger one, identify which staffing, vendor and reporting costs are property-paid or billed separately.
| Compare | Enter for each firm | Ask before deciding |
|---|---|---|
| Base management fee | Rate or fixed amount, fee base and minimum | Which receipts count and how are reversals, late fees and other charges treated? |
| Leasing, renewals and turns | Per-event charges, included work and exclusions | Who supplies leasing coverage, readiness checks and work approval? |
| Maintenance and vendors | After-hours coverage, markup, project fees and pass-through costs | Who approves ordinary, emergency and out-of-scope work? |
| Books and owner reporting | Example packet, report date, account scope and reconciliation owner | Who ties manager activity to the owner’s books and bank? |
| Start and exit | Setup costs, handoff owner, records exports and termination terms | Which records are delivered at cutoff and who resolves outstanding items? |
Run one fictional month through both quotes
At $30,000 of collections and two new leases, fictional Proposal A charges 6% of collections plus $400 per new lease, or $2,600. Fictional Proposal B charges 7% plus $150 per new lease, or $2,400. Compare any different minimums, reporting scope, after-hours support and vendor charges before deciding. These are invented terms for the worksheet.